photo
People wait in line for a decision from the California State Supreme Court on the legality of a voter-approved ban on same-sex marriages, Tuesday, May 26, 2009, in San Francisco.   CREDIT: The Associated Press: Paul Sakuma
breaking news
California Supreme Court upholds same-sex marriage ban
Protests planned locally, statewide
Published Thursday, 21-May-2009 in issue 1117
The California Supreme Court upheld a voter-approved ban on same-sex marriage Tuesday, but it also decided that the estimated 18,000 same-sex couples who tied the knot before the law took effect will stay wed.
The 6-1 decision written by Chief Justice Ron George rejected an argument by gay rights activists that the ban revised the California constitution’s equal protection clause to such a dramatic degree that it first needed the Legislature’s approval.
The court said the people have a right, through the ballot box, to change their constitution.
“In a sense, petitioners’ and the attorney general’s complaint is that it is just too easy to amend the California constitution through the initiative process. But it is not a proper function of this court to curtail that process; we are constitutionally bound to uphold it,” the ruling said.
The announcement of the decision set off an outcry among a sea of demonstrators who had gathered in front of the San Francisco courthouse awaiting the ruling. Holding signs and many waving rainbow flags, they chanted “shame on you.” Many people also held hands in a chain around an intersection in an act of protest.
Gay rights activists immediately promised to resume their fight, saying they would go back to voters as early as next year in a bid to repeal Proposition 8.
The split decision provided some relief for the 18,000 same-sex couples who married in the brief time same-sex marriage was legal last year but that wasn’t enough to dull the anger over the ruling that banned same-sex marriage.
“It’s not about whether we get to stay married. Our fight is far from over,” said Jeannie Rizzo, 62, who was one of the lead plaintiffs along with her wife, Polly Cooper. “I have about 20 years left on this earth, and I’m going to continue to fight for equality every day.”
The state Supreme Court had ruled last May that it was unconstitutional to deny same-sex couples the right to wed. Many same-sex couples had rushed to get married before the November vote on Proposition 8, fearing it could be passed. When it was, gay rights activists went back to the court arguing that the ban was improperly put to voters.
That was the issue justices decided today.
“After comparing this initiative measure to the many other constitutional changes that have been reviewed and evaluated in numerous prior decisions of this court, we conclude Proposition 8 constitutes a constitutional amendment rather than a constitutional revision,” the ruling said.
Today’s ruling of “no” and “yes” on same-sex marriage effectively left many people in the fight for equality with mixed emotions.
Locally, the San Diego LGBT Community Center expressed deep disappointment in the ruling from the California State Supreme Court, which failed to overturn Proposition 8. While the court did not invalidate the marriages performed for same-sex couples between June and November of last year, today’s ruling is a “major disappointment from a court that ruled for full equality just a year ago,” said Dr. Delores A. Jacobs, chief executive officer of The San Diego LGBT Community Center.
“It’s difficult to find joy in the fact that our state’s highest court didn’t forcibly ‘divorce’ the couples who were married last year,” Jacobs said. “There can be no doubt that our outrage would be considerably greater had those marriages been invalidated, but there is no cause for celebration. The bottom line is that justice and equality did not prevail today for anyone, and the Court has declared that Californians can simply vote to strip away even the most fundamental rights to equality enjoyed by their friends, family and neighbors.”
Those closest to the fight were angered.
“No civil rights movement has ever lost. Never. It is not a matter of if our community will win full equal rights, including marriage,” said Robin Tyler, a petitioner in the case to overturn Proposition 8. “It is only a matter of when. But as in all civil rights movements, we will have to fight like hell for it.”
While it didn’t leave the community feeling victorious, some solace was found because a component of today’s ruling protects the 18,000 same-sex marriages, which were performed during the six months when same-sex marriage was legal in California.
“While we are relieved that the High Court’s decision will not annul the marriages of the 18,000 committed couples who were legally wed between June and November of 2008, we are deeply saddened that others will not enjoy the same social and economic justice,” said Sara Beth Brooks, spokesperson for the San Diego Equality Campaign, one of seven civil rights organizations hosting this evening’s march and protest.
“Today, the State Supreme Court failed to perform one of its primary responsibilities, which is to protect minority groups from the whim of the majority. In November, a narrow majority of California voters stripped away marriage rights from same-sex couples, denying them 1,058 civil rights and legal protections that are not granted by civil unions or domestic partnerships,” Brooks said. “Denying one group the right to marry goes against the very grain of the American principles of fairness and equality.”
“Some will argue simply that ‘majority rules,’ but these people lack a basic understanding of the function of the High Court and American democracy,” said Brooks. “At several points in history, the Court or Legislature stepped in to correct social injustices, such as slavery and racial segregation, even though the abhorrent practices had vast majority support.”
Local Day of Decision protests and rallies in San Diego
Locally marriage-equality supporters will meet at Sixth Avenue and Laurel Street in Balboa Park at 5 p.m. With Proposition 8 upheld, attendees will march south down Sixth Avenue and then west on Broadway to the Hall of Justice, where a rally will be held.
The San Diego Chapter of Marriage Equality USA, San Diego Alliance for Marriage Equality, and the San Diego Equality Campaign are organizing the event. For more information, visit www.dayofdecision.com.
This Saturday, May 30, statewide activists and organizations will meet at Fresno City Hall at 1 p.m. Why Fresno? Marriage equality has to be fought, not only in gay friendly cities like San Francisco and Los Angeles but in towns like Fresno, where the population is far more reflective of national attitudes toward GLBT equality. Buses and caravans will be offered but those with transportation are encouraged to carpool. Fresno City Hall is located at 2600 Fresno Street in Fresno, California. For more information, visit www.meetinthemiddle4equality.com.
The Associated Press contributed to this story.
E-mail

Send the story “California Supreme Court upholds same-sex marriage ban”

Recipient's e-mail: 
Your e-mail: 
Additional note: 
(optional) 
E-mail Story     Print Print Story     Share Bookmark & Share Story
Classifieds Place a Classified Ad Business Directory Real Estate
Contact Advertise About GLT