national
Custody battle could be first test of new anti-gay law
Case first to reach state’s court since restrictive law took effect July 1
Published Thursday, 19-Aug-2004 in issue 869
RICHMOND, Va. (AP) – A woman who had a child with her lesbian partner after entering into a civil union in Vermont is now suing for custody in Virginia, where a new law recently went into effect banning civil unions and other same-sex partnership contracts. A ruling on the case is expected to come Aug. 24.
The state’s leading gay rights organization, Equality Virginia, said the lawsuit could bring the first challenge to Virginia’s anti-gay law, which many legal scholars call the most restrictive in the nation.
A hearing in a Winchester court will determine whether Lisa Miller-Jenkins has sole parental rights over her biological daughter, 2-year-old Isabella. Lisa’s former partner, Janet Miller-Jenkins, is contesting the action, claiming Vermont has jurisdiction over the case.
Though Lisa Miller-Jenkins carried the child, Janet Miller-Jenkins said the women selected a sperm donor with her physical characteristics so the child would look like the two of them. After Isabella was born in April 2002, both women cared for her. Janet Miller-Jenkins did not adopt Isabella because she was assured she had legal rights to the child under the couple’s civil union.
When the women dissolved their civil union last year, they agreed to allow a Vermont judge to decide custody. However, Lisa Miller-Jenkins took the girl with her when she moved to Winchester in September and sued for full custody in Virginia, where civil unions are not recognized.
“I think it’s a simple case of determining who the biological parent of Isabella is,” said Lisa’s attorney, Phil Griffin. “Custody obviously flows from whoever the parents are.”
But Janet Miller-Jenkins’ attorney, Joseph Price, said the dispute is more complicated. Because Lisa Miller-Jenkins has violated a court order in Vermont granting Janet Miller-Jenkins certain visitation rights, Janet Miller-Jenkins is pressing for full custody in that state.
Price, who is also chair of Equality Virginia, said Vermont has jurisdiction over the case because a judge there has already rendered a temporary custody order.
“We don’t want to have these cases where one parent gets a ruling in one state and grabs the child and runs to another state to get another ruling,” he said.
Same-sex marriage is illegal in Virginia, and the state’s Republican-dominated Legislature earlier this year extended that ban to cover civil unions and other contracts “purporting to bestow the privileges or obligations of marriage.”
The move outraged the GLBT community, prompting Equality Virginia and other gay rights groups to threaten a lawsuit to challenge the law’s constitutionality.
The child custody case is the first to reach Virginia’s courts since the law took effect July 1.
Steve Cable, president of an anti-gay group called the Center for American Cultural Renewal, said the fact that Vermont civil unions are not valid in Virginia means that Janet Miller-Jenkins’ temporary joint custody order does not have any bearing in Virginia.
“Part of what this is about is the legal chaos civil unions have created,” Cable said.
But Price said Virginia’s new law and others like it around the country are what are causing the confusion.
“Without this law, no argument would have been made that Janet, who raised Isabella, should not have rights to care for her and love her as she has since the baby was born,” he said.
E-mail

Send the story “Custody battle could be first test of new anti-gay law”

Recipient's e-mail: 
Your e-mail: 
Additional note: 
(optional) 
E-mail Story     Print Print Story     Share Bookmark & Share Story
Classifieds Place a Classified Ad Business Directory Real Estate
Contact Advertise About GLT