photo
Chief Justice William Rehnquist died Sept. 3.
national
Chief Justice William Rehnquist dies, John Roberts to succeed him
Conservative head of Supreme Court voted consistently against GLBT equality during tenure
Published Thursday, 08-Sep-2005 in issue 924
Supreme Court Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist succumbed to thyroid cancer on Sept. 3 at the age of 80. He had served on the court for 33 years, first as a justice and then as chief justice. It was one of the longest tenures in the court’s history.
President George W. Bush wasted no time in announcing Supreme Court nominee John G. Roberts as the successor to Rehnquist, on the morning of Sept. 5. Twenty-five years ago Roberts served as a law clerk to the elder jurist.
Rehnquist was a conservative and he certainly helped to move the court in that direction, but there was no wholesale rolling back of precedents with which he disagreed. His greatest influence on jurisprudence was in the areas of restricting the power of Congress to enact legislation and the immunity of state governments from federal law.
Despite his long tenure, Rehnquist’s name was associated with few groundbreaking precedents; in fact, he often was in the minority on the most noteworthy cases decided over those years. His strongest legacy is his commitment to the courts as an institution and his efforts to strengthen their administration.
The GLBT community had little reason to mourn his passing as Rehnquist’s vote consistently fell in opposition to equal treatment of gays and lesbians under the law. He joined with the majority in the 1986 Hardwick decision that endorsed the state of Georgia’s right to enact and enforce anti-gay sodomy laws.
He was in the dissenting minority when the court saw fit to protect gay and lesbian Americans in the Romer case by striking down Colorado’s Amendment 2, in 1996, and when the court overturned Hardwick with the Lawrence decision in 2003.
And yet, while he had ample opportunity to pen either the majority decision or a dissent on these cases, Rehnquist chose not to do so, leaving that task to others. It suggests that anti-gay animus was not a driving factor in his life.
The late chief justice’s body lay in repose for public viewing at the Supreme Court on Tuesday. Burial at Arlington National Cemetery, beside his wife Natalie who died of cancer in 1991, was scheduled for Wednesday.
The ambivalence over Rehnquist was reflected in the response of national GLBT organizations. While his death did occur over a holiday weekend, none of those organizations had issued press releases on his passing until two days after it was announced.
Senator Charles Schumer, D-New York, a member of the Judiciary Committee who voted against Roberts’ confirmation to the D.C. circuit Court of Appeals two years ago, called for the committee to delay the confirmation hearing on Roberts “to mourn Justice Rehnquist,” when he appeared on a Sunday political talk show.
But with the announcement that Roberts is being put forward to succeed Rehnquist, there is little likelihood that those hearings will be delayed more than a few days, though that is still in flux.
Most political observers believed that Roberts was virtually assured of confirmation to the court. His nomination to be chief justice has, if anything, enhanced those odds. He will be succeeding one of the most conservative members of the court, not Sandra Day O’Connor, who has been more of a swing vote on issues of concern to liberals.
Those who have opposed Roberts’ confirmation often have tried to frame it as a “replacement” for O’Connor. Now they will be deprived of that rhetoric.
O’Connor is likely to be sitting on the bench when the court convenes for its new session on the first Monday in October. In a clause in her very brief letter of resignation, which was little noted at the time, she said it becomes effective “upon the nomination and confirmation of my successor.”
Speculation is rife as to who the president will nominate to the court. It centers on the same names raised earlier this year, though there is a heightened sense that the nominee will not be another white male.
Regardless of who is nominated, the investigation and confirmation process will take several months. The earliest that a successor justice is likely to be sworn in is the second half of the session, which beings in January. Controversy over a nominee could push that back farther.
E-mail

Send the story “Chief Justice William Rehnquist dies, John Roberts to succeed him”

Recipient's e-mail: 
Your e-mail: 
Additional note: 
(optional) 
E-mail Story     Print Print Story     Share Bookmark & Share Story
Classifieds Place a Classified Ad Business Directory Real Estate
Contact Advertise About GLT